The Board of Education Sees a Rise in Patron Comments Amidst Controversial Topics
Published: December 13, 2021
The FHSD Board of Education has had a busy year with controversial votes on everything from the district’s masking policy to what to do with the increased cost projections of the new FHN building.
The masking policy, where masks are required for Elementary schoolers but optional for Middle and High school students, has come under heat recently. It may be changed at the Dec. 16 meeting. Some groups, like Francis Howell Families, believe that masks should not be required at any level, and other groups believe in masking every student. Both sides are very vocal about their opinion. At some meetings, patrons have been asked to leave after using vulgar language.
“We used to only have one officer at our meetings, now we have between two and three,” board member Patrick Lane said.
Patron comments are when community members speak at board meetings to give feedback on district policy. This is one of the primary ways people can get their opinion to the board.
“Patron comments were once one to four people per meeting, mostly announcements and curricular concerns, small stuff,” Lane said.
However, in the past 18 months, more and more people have started showing up at the board meetings. And they’ve been getting more rowdy. At the Oct. 21 meeting, a man shouted obscenities at the patron speaking and was asked to leave. The current patron comments system, where the first ten people in line get to speak, has come under heat recently for not allowing all voices to be heard.
“First come, first served system has worked, but both sides need to be heard,” Lane said.
The board will be discussing the district’s mask policy on Dec. 16, and that is expected to rile up the crowd, but the mask policy isn’t the only thing causing tension. Groups like Francis Howell Families urge the school board to ban a string of ‘inappropriate’ books from school libraries, and to stop the Black Literature and Black History classes from being taught in the district.
“We have many people very concerned about Black History and Lit, and we have a list of ‘problem’ books,” Lane said.
Even the students have been getting involved. Sophomore Grant Kilen has been attending board meetings since June, when the Black History and Black Lit. classes were first voted on.
“Previously, it was like watching a game, it was all speculative,” Kilen said. “But recently, it’s gotten more close to home.”
Lane is one of seven board members who make decisions about the district’s finances and choose the superintendent. The Board is non-partisan and also makes policy changes for the district.
“The election is non-partisan, but everyone has biases, we all have them,” Doug Ziegemeier said.
Ziegemeier is a retired law enforcement officer and small business owner, and is another Board director. One of his responsibilities on the board is managing the district’s finances.
“With the finances we have, it’s like a big business,” Ziegemeier said. “We have a budget in excess of $200 million”
Even when patrons are feuding, the Board itself works together to perform their duties. They all remain respectful and work together despite their differing ideologies.
“We don’t get paid,” Lane said, “Remember that.”
Grant Kilen • Dec 20, 2021 at 6:12 pm
They really are very different than before. It went from sometimes having no public comment to a maxed-out public comment and usually a full auditorium. Not only that, there is a clear political divide. The conservatives, such as FHF, tend to sit towards the left of the auditorium and the progressives towards the right. I’m really interested in seeing how the board is made up after this coming election. The voters of Francis Howell voted an average of about 55% Republican to about 40% Democrat (the 5% in between being third parties) during the statewide elections of November 2016 and November 2020, according to the county election authority. But even with an R+15 electorate, I wonder if the conservative groups (Francis Howell Families, SCC Parents Association) can organize enough to beat out the incumbents this coming April. FHF and SCCPA’s de facto nomination of Adam Bertrand (a financial director from Weldon Spring) and Randy Cook (a civil engineer from St Peters) has left board member Mike Hoehn in a curious position. Hoehn also sits on the county republican central committee so you would think he would attract the favor of the conservatives. However, his past votes to adopt the black history and literature classes as well as his votes to maintain mask mandates instead drew their ire. Nevertheless, their omission of him certainly does not do them any favors with the old Republican establishment in St Charles County. Despite this, the continued support of local state representatives and senators may be able to prevent a conservative vote splinter that would be potentially fatal to the Bertrand-Cook campaign. I may be overthinking the whole thing though; we all know how few people vote in April and the incumbents/progressives/FHEA might not be able to even get close given the current conservative enthusiasm. Regardless I have a feeling Hoehn is out as a school board member.
Thanks for giving me a call for this one. I really enjoyed talking with Ben and Mr. Lane. I’d love to work with you guys again on something similar to this; don’t hesitate to contact me!