The Fangirl Life: Captain America vs. Superman
Published: September 19, 2016
Two American icons, both heavily symbolic of the American ideals, are in two separate universes: one in DC, the other in Marvel. Superman and Captain America are both muscular men who are idolized by the characters in the comics and/or movies.
If put in a fight, it would be difficult to determine at the beginning to determine who would win. But Superman may come out on top with his inhuman, other world strength. His abilities would put him on top. Let’s not forget about Steve Rogers though. His personality would allow him to continue picking himself up and fighting.
What I love about both characters is their loyalty to those around them. For Steve, it’s those he fights alongside. For Superman, it’s Lois Lane. What makes me lean more towards Captain America is his background. He was just a kid from Brooklyn who was skinny and weak yet stood up for what he believed in no matter what.He didn’t take no for an answer when he continued to be rejected from serving in the army. Then when he finally got into the army, he was ridiculed by the other soldiers. This carried over when Dr. Erskine gave Steve the super soldier serum which amplified everything about him whether physical or not.
Steve is human, emotionally and genetically. Nothing against Superman, but it’s just interesting the drastic physical change Captain America went through yet remained the same with his personality. He has feelings. He goes through hardships. He faces defeat and loss. But he doesn’t give up, and that’s what is so great about Captain America.
Comic Guy (and writer) • Oct 8, 2016 at 11:43 am
First of all, quite a bit of typos. (not to be annoying or a grammar nazi, but I work at my school as a coach to improve people’s writing so I have a habit of suggesting improvements) For example, “it would be difficult to determine at the beginning to determine who would..” You say “determine” twice. I would recommend finding a friend or some other author to check your work before posting or try reading it aloud to yourself! You’d be surprised how easily these to steps squash all grammatical issues! Second, you never really address the main idea. You seem to be trying to take a stance on who would win in this fight, yet you discuss the moral values of the characters. Although this may be a factor that contributes to how they fight, you never make this clear in your argument. Are you saying that Cap would win because his personal resilience would pull him through? By the way, there’s no such thing as a wrong argument, you just need to make your overall argument clear, and ensure that you come to a firm conclusion in the end. Go back and ask yourself what question your trying to answer. I want to let the comic fan in me come out, and assess the points in this whole article, but that would be hypocritical of me because, like I said, there is no such thing as a wrong argument. Follow my advice, and I’m sure you’ll write many intriguing articles. I’m always interested in the ideas of fellow comic fans!